- Audience 1st
- Posts
- The Difference Between a Startup CISO and an Enterprise CISO
The Difference Between a Startup CISO and an Enterprise CISO
Think CISOs are all the same? Think again. Startup CISOs juggle roles, scrape for budget, and demand true partnerships, while enterprise CISOs navigate red tape and legacy systems.
Dani Woolf
19 Jan • Read Time: 10 minutes
Imagine trying to build a robust security program with only two people on your team, no budget for new hires, and every dollar scrutinized.
Now, compare that to managing a security operation with a team of 100, layers of red tape, and a tech stack so outdated it makes you cringe.
Welcome to the worlds of startup and enterprise CISOs—two vastly different realities that require two entirely different approaches."
In this episode, James Azar, a seasoned cybersecurity leader with experience in both startups and billion-dollar enterprises, pulls back the curtain on what it’s really like to be a CISO in both worlds.
With his candid and no-BS approach, James shares the unique pressures that define these roles.
From running lean operations in startups to maneuvering bureaucratic mazes in enterprises, James has seen it all.
He compares the challenges of building security programs in shoestring-budget startups—where creativity and “zero waste” efficiency are non-negotiable—to the uphill battle of pushing initiatives through siloed teams and legacy processes in large organizations.
James doesn’t hold back as he dives into what separates a "vendor" from a "partner," how startups force CISOs to become security architects, engineers, and even accountants, and why enterprise CISOs often find themselves fighting inertia more than vulnerabilities.
His insights not only reveal how different these roles are, but also highlight what marketers and sales teams need to know to truly resonate with these distinct audiences.
POLL: What's your biggest challenge in adding value to CISO conversations? |
Before we dive in, don’t forget to subscribe to join 1700+ cybersecurity marketers and sales pros mastering customer research. You’ll get notified whenever a new episode and buyer insights summary drops.
Who is James Azar?
James Azar is a seasoned cybersecurity professional with over two decades of experience in information security, privacy, geopolitics, and cybercrime.
He currently serves as the Chief Technology Officer (CTO) and Chief Security Officer (CSO) at AP4 Group.
Throughout his career, James has held various leadership roles, including CTO and CISO positions, where he has led information security, DevSecOps, AppSec, and engineering teams.
His expertise lies at the intersection of security and business, where he applies innovative and out-of-the-box thinking to drive security growth within organizations.
James is known for his strategic and entrepreneurial approach to cybersecurity, with experience in both startup and enterprise environments.
He is dedicated to aligning technology, security, and privacy with business goals, solving complex challenges head-on.
As a thought leader in the industry, James hosts the CISO Talk podcast, a part of the CyberHub Podcast network.
He regularly shares insights on cybersecurity, privacy, technology, and geopolitics through various media channels.
James has been featured on major news outlets such as Fox, OANN, NBC, and the Atlanta Journal-Constitution.
He maintains a Substack newsletter where he discusses the latest news and topics in cybersecurity from a practitioner's perspective.
His writings cover a wide range of subjects, including data security, privacy, and cybercrime.
James Azar's diverse background, extensive experience, and commitment to sharing knowledge make him a respected voice in the cybersecurity community.
His approach combines technical expertise with business acumen, reflecting the evolving nature of cybersecurity leadership in today's complex digital landscape.
Pro Tip for Connecting with James
If you want to connect with James Azar, skip the buzzwords and get straight to the point.
He’s all about clarity and real-world impact, so lead with value by showing how your solution directly addresses his security goals—whether it’s boosting efficiency, improving integration, or maximizing tight budgets.
James isn’t looking for a quick sale; he’s seeking genuine partnerships.
Engage him with curiosity about his challenges, and be ready to adapt and collaborate.
Consistency is key—stay in touch with regular check-ins and relevant updates, even if there’s no immediate need. Above all, show that you’re in it for the long haul.
Insights and Key Takeaways
Understanding the Differences: Startup vs. Enterprise CISO
Insight: The Role of a Startup CISO is Vastly Different from an Enterprise CISO
In startups, CISOs handle a broader range of responsibilities, from building security programs from scratch to being hands-on with architecture, engineering, compliance, and even privacy.
Startup CISOs are hands-on in every aspect of security.
The budget constraints are significant, forcing CISOs to be resourceful and squeeze maximum value out of limited resources.
The startup CISO must also be adept at negotiating vendor partnerships, as strong relationships are critical for success.
Conversely, enterprise CISOs focus more on strategic initiatives, bridging departments, and working with VIPs, directors, and other stakeholders.
In larger enterprises, CISOs spend less time on operational security and more on aligning security programs with business goals.
They often act as intermediaries, translating security needs to executive teams and securing budget approvals.
The hierarchical nature of enterprises adds layers of separation, slowing down decision-making and sometimes stifling innovation.
“So, you're a CISO, but you're a security architect, a security engineer, and an analyst. You’re dabbling with compliance and privacy, and you're doing everything on a shoestring budget.”
This difference in roles should shape how vendors and GTM teams approach CISOs—emphasizing efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and partnership is key when selling to startup CISOs, while focusing on strategic alignment and ROI is more relevant for enterprise CISOs.
Maturity of Security Teams: A Complex Reality
Insight: Defining Maturity in Security Teams Varies by Organization
Security maturity doesn’t always equate to a more effective team.
Startups can achieve high efficiency with lean teams, while larger enterprises may have established processes that are outdated, but difficult to change.
In startups, CISOs often build teams of highly skilled individuals who excel at solving complex problems.
Budget constraints in startups push CISOs to ensure every hire brings critical skills, while enterprises might face internal resistance to revamping legacy systems, even when necessary.
Enterprises may have larger teams that lack innovation, as they focus more on maintaining existing systems.
“I thought I had a very mature security team because I hired very smart people to do very smart work. In larger enterprises, teams can be in play not due to maturity but because of immaturity and lack of innovation.”
Vendors need to understand that startups are likely to look for tools that maximize impact with minimal resources, while enterprises require solutions that can integrate with legacy systems and processes.
The Bleeding Neck Challenge: Budget
Insight: Budget Constraints are a Persistent Issue for Startup CISOs
The biggest challenge for startup CISOs is securing adequate funding.
Every conversation revolves around budget, making financial literacy an essential skill for CISOs.
Startup CISOs often struggle to secure sufficient budget, and as funding rounds occur, they must ensure that security receives appropriate allocation.
This challenge extends beyond obtaining initial funds—CISOs must understand the organization’s budgeting processes to maximize spending across different “buckets” within the company.
“If I took an enterprise role again, I would have an accountant for my security team, someone who understands how the company's budgeting works so that I can maximize my budget gap.”
GTM teams should be prepared to present cost-effective solutions and demonstrate how their product aligns with the CISO’s budget limitations and strategic goals.
Building Strong Partnerships: No Room for Transactional Relationships
Insight: Startup CISOs Prioritize Partners, Not Vendors
Startup CISOs are looking for vendors who act as partners.
Vendors must be ready to offer real-time support and demonstrate their commitment to the security program.
The term “vendor” is almost a red flag for startup CISOs, who seek true partners capable of filling the gaps in their lean teams.
This partnership mindset extends to the decision-making process:
CISOs expect vendors to offer flexible pricing, adapt to changing needs, and even join calls during off-hours if necessary.
“If you can be a partner, great. If not, we probably won’t work together. I’m not interested in your logo; I’m interested in having you be a security partner to my program.”
Vendors should focus on demonstrating their potential as long-term partners rather than selling a product.
Showing a willingness to adapt and offer support beyond the initial purchase can make the difference.
Security Maturity is Harder to Achieve in Enterprises
Insight: Security Maturity is Often a Bigger Challenge in Enterprises
Enterprises have complex tech stacks and decision-making processes, which complicate the path to maturity.
In larger organizations, mature teams might exist, but the tech stack can be outdated, and processes often slow down progress.
Budgeting practices also complicate things—security teams might buy tools they only partially use to avoid losing budget allocations.
“You end up buying things that you only maybe need 5% of, but you’re buying it to spend the money so that you don’t lose that budget next year.”
GTM teams should emphasize the flexibility and integration capabilities of their solutions when selling to enterprise CISOs.
The Value of Podcasting in Cybersecurity
Insight: Podcasting is an Effective Medium for Engaging CISOs
Podcasting offers an efficient way for CISOs to digest information amidst their busy schedules.
CISOs spend hours reading reports, white papers, and research documents, which can be mentally exhausting.
Podcasts offer a break from reading while still providing valuable insights in a digestible format.
The conversational nature of podcasts makes it easier to connect on an emotional level, creating stronger community ties.
“Podcasting is all about the ability to articulate ourselves and create a community. You feel something when you and I talk, and people who listen relate to our personalities based on how our voice makes them feel.”
Marketers and salespeople should consider podcasting as a key channel to reach CISOs and other security practitioners, as it offers a more engaging way to communicate complex information.
TL;DR
The role of a CISO, whether in a startup or enterprise, is not just about securing networks but building relationships.
In startups, the lack of resources means every decision counts—every dollar spent, every partnership formed, every tool used. In enterprises, it’s about navigating bureaucracy and pushing for innovation.
Regardless of the setting, one truth stands out: security is about people. It’s not enough to offer products; you need to offer solutions tailored to real-world challenges.
If you’re not ready to be a partner in this journey, you’re in the wrong room.
Until next time,
Dani
Subscribe to Audience 1st Podcast Newsletter
Thanks for reading! If you like summaries like this, subscribe to Audience 1st Podcast Newsletter to get notified whenever a new episode drops.
Excited to collaborate? Let’s make it happen!
Check out our sponsorship details to connect with real security practitioners and showcase your brand to an engaged community of cybersecurity decision-makers giving and seeking real buyer insights.
Reply